Ecological Principles for

Sustainable Forestry on BC’s Coast

David Suzuki Foundation’s

Turning Point

Guiding principles (from summary)

 

Principle 1

Make the well-being of the lands and waters the fundamental goal of management

Principle 2

Plan forest practices in a hierarchy,

starting with the “big picture” level

Principle 3

Establish a rate-of-cut that sustains the integrity of the forest.

Principle 4

Ensure local knowledge and control are central to decision-making and planning

Principle 5

Conserve all native plants and animals.

Principle 6

Protect rivers, streams, lakes, and marine shores

Principle 7

Focus on what to retain rather than

what to remove.

 

Principle 8

Restore degraded landscapes, forests, and sites.

Principle 9

Acknowledge uncertainty, act cautiously, and monitor the consequences of forest practices

Cut Above report author

Ronnie Drever MRM

.


Terminology

Ecological sustainability

In this report, ecological sustainability is defined as the maintenance of biological diversity and ecosystem integrity at multiple scales of time and space (Scientific Panel, 1995).

Ecosystem integrity

integrity is maintained when an ecosystem is both resistant, i.e., has the capacity to absorb small disturbances and prevent them from amplifying into large disturbances, and resilient, i.e., has the capacity to return to a given level of productivity and species composition following a disturbance

Precautionary principle

This principle states: “When an activity raises threats of harm to human health or the environment, precautionary measures should be taken even if some cause and effect relationships are not fully established scientifically. In this context the proponent of an activity, rather than the public, should bear the burden of proof.”


Ecological units

ECOLOGICAL SUB-UNITS

The study area can be divided into three distinct ecological sub-units: the Hecate Lowland, the Outer Coast Mountains, the Inner Coast Mountains  (Pojar ’99 modofied)

Example differences

 Outer Coast Mountains receive higher rainfall and have steeper topography than the Hecate Lowland, making landslides an important contributor to the natural disturbance regime of the Outer Coast Mountains.

This means a higher standard of care is necessary in the Outer Coast Mountains during the planning and building of logging roads to minimize the potential for landslides

(Note the subtle differences in unit boundaries from left figure attributed to Pojar 1999 & right MOF Guide 1993 both modified by LG The Guide appears better resolution of detail & includes CWHwm and easier ‘see’ alpine elevations)

 


From Principle 5

Best practicesCAD on central coast

Central Coast Conservation Area Design (CAD) has been conducted for the central coast (Jeo and others, 1999). It used three taxa as focal species: Grizzly Bears, salmon stocks and selected tree species.

 

 As mentioned previously, these taxa play a keystone role in coastal forests. The CAD is based on the assumption that the conservation of habitat for these taxa will “help conserve biodiversity at natural levels of abundance and distribution,” as well as allow “preservation of ecotypes and ecosystem

 

From Principle 6

Best practices #1: the NW Aquatic Conservation Strategy

 

In the federal forest lands of western Washington, western Oregon and northwestern California, the protection of hydroriparian areas is legislated by the Aquatic Conservation Strategy of the Northwest Forest Plan4. Under the Aquatic Conservation Strategy, Riparian Reserves form the principal component of a strategy that has as its overarching goal “to maintain and restore the productivity and resiliency of riparian and aquatic ecosystems” (USDA and USDI, 1994). The three other components of the Aquatic Conservation

 

Best practices #2 Clayoquot Sound Scientific Panel Recommendations for Hydroriparian Management

Compare these with Riparian area management under the Forest Practices Code. Table 1 with no reserves but its “management zones for fish bearing streams under 1.5m widths etc.

 

From Principle 7

Best practices Variable-Retention Silvicultural System

The Clayoquot Sound Scientific Panel recommended adopting a Variable-Retention Silvicultural System to replace conventional silvicultural systems. The primary goal of this system is to maintain ecological integrity, i.e., to retain characteristics of natural forests in managed stands so that ecosystem functions do not depart from the range of natural variability present before harvest

 

From Principle 9

Best practices Effectiveness Monitoring Program

The USDA Forest Service has begun an Effectiveness Monitoring Program (EMP) to assess whether the goals of the Northwest Forest Plan are being met